Representation Case Study- gender

 Case Study: Gender in Film – Context and Representations 

  • When you used to look at gender representation you only looked at representation for women. 

  • This comes from the traditional role of women until the later part of the 20th century. 

  • Lower status 

  • Most media rep. was made by men 

  • Rep. of women relied on their relationships with men 

  • Modern gender theory concentrated on rep. of women and the effects of said rep. 

  • Since the 1970s , women’s role in society has changed. 

  • No longer expected to take on domestic roles in society 

  • Since women’s role in society has changed, men’s has too 

  • Gender theory has now begun to acknowledge and research men’s roles in society. 

  • What is Masculinity? 

  • Definitions of masculinity are culturally and historically specific 

  • Hegemonic masculinities: the dominant sets of values that define the ideals of male behavior.  

  • The dominant values of each culture can be seen to be reflected in gender ideals based on a social aspects of a society. 

  • The Working Class Male(Culturally Determined): 

  • key masculine traits can be seen across the early 20th century, these can be used to identify conventional ideas of masculinity: 

  • head of the household, and breadwinner 

  • family depends on him 

  • masculine status in the workplace 

  • either manual laborer or in charge of workers 

  • free to follow his own interests 

Feminine Qualities 

Masculine Qualities 

Emotional 

Emotionless 

Sensitive 

Tough 

Domestic 

Breadwinner 

Sexually Passive 

Sexual initiator 

Quiet 

Loud 

Submissive 

Dominant 

A communicator 

Uncommunicative  

Physically Weak 

Strong 

Decorative 

Handsome 

The damsel who needs saving 

The white knight 

Fluid and adaptable 

Fixed and Solid 

  • Social Changes since the 1970s 

  • Many changes in society have also changed the roles of men and women. 

  • A UK law in 1972 made it illegal to pay women less than men that had the same job. It become illegal to discriminate against women, then it was not socially acceptable to see women as ‘less than’ 

  • Divorce become more common and accepted socially. 

  • From the 1960s onwards, birth control became more widely available 

  • Through the 1970s and onwards, it was more acceptable for women to have social lives 

  • In the 1980s working practices changed as traditionally masculine jobs in manufacturing and heavy industry declined and the service industry boomed. 

  • Recent social changes have made defining what it means to be a man more challenging. 

  • Activity #2 

  • I think the roles may have had less emphasis put on them, with more fluidity being allowed to the different genders. For example, now it is much more common for women to go out and work and the men to stay home with the kids if the woman makes more than the man. However, this has not had much of a shift on the role of men in the workplace, as they still more often than not hold higher positions in the workplace than women. 

  • The Action Genre as a Response – Reclaiming Masculine Identity 

  • The action genre rose to popularity in the 1980s 

  • Two main types of hero 

  • Characters depicted by actors like Stallone and Schwarzenegger 

  • Focus on the male body and “pumped up” masculinity 

  • Attempts to reinstate an idea of male strength and power through the visual representations of a muscular body 

  • Fantasy males  

  • Able to ignore the social changes which had maginalised the need for extreme strength 

  • Slightly more realistic hero’s portrayed by Willis and Gibson 

  • Also embody trad. Masculine traits 

  • More attainable aspirational ideal 

  • Represents an idea of the working class male 

  • can be seen as nostalgic of a time when men’s roles were clearly defined and their place in society was certain 

  • Activity #3 

  • When thinking of 80s action heroes, the traits I would think of are strong, masculine, and dumb, but smart in relation to everyone else. The hero’s of the 80s were often strong and tough to be able to save the “damsels in distress”. The embodied the masculine archetypes often associated with men of the past. This made them honestly, by modern standards, pretty stupid. However, in relation to everyone else around them, they appeared clever and quick witted.  

  • Activity #4 

  • Other stereotypes of masculine identity include holding authority, being smart, but not too smart, and having emotional control. These stereotypes carry over not just with masculine men, but to women who are deemed as masculine as well. The stereotypes generate from the previous societal roles of men in America, where they would be seen as breadwinners and head of homes.  

  • Modern Representations of Masculinity 

  • In modern texts, the idea of masculinity is challenged and questioned. 

  • In two recent hero films, traditional masculine identity is rejected, without losing any heroic power. 

  • The protags integrate both masc and fem traits in to their identities. 

  • Conventional action films try to reinforce the opposites of gender identity. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Camera Angle Assignment

Mise-en-scene Case Study Activity 1

Final Exam